diff --git a/common/content/autocommands.js b/common/content/autocommands.js
index 8aad6061..919ab2a3 100644
--- a/common/content/autocommands.js
+++ b/common/content/autocommands.js
@@ -110,7 +110,7 @@ const AutoCommands = Module("autocommands", {
      * @param {Object} args The args to pass to each autocommand.
      */
     trigger: function (event, args) {
-        if (options.get("eventignore").has("all", event))
+        if (options.get("eventignore").has(event))
             return;
 
         let autoCmds = this._store.filter(function (autoCmd) autoCmd.event == event);
@@ -269,7 +269,8 @@ const AutoCommands = Module("autocommands", {
             "List of autocommand event names which should be ignored",
             "stringlist", "",
             {
-                completer: function () Iterator(update({ all: "All Events" }, config.autocommands))
+                completer: function () Iterator(update({ all: "All Events" }, config.autocommands)),
+                has: Option.has.toggleAll
             });
     }
 });
diff --git a/common/content/dactyl.js b/common/content/dactyl.js
index e1bbe6b7..1ea01244 100644
--- a/common/content/dactyl.js
+++ b/common/content/dactyl.js
@@ -797,9 +797,9 @@ const Dactyl = Module("dactyl", {
                                                   : params.where == dactyl.NEW_BACKGROUND_TAB;
 
         if (params.from && dactyl.has("tabs")) {
-            if (!params.where && options.get("newtab").has("all", params.from))
+            if (!params.where && options.get("newtab").has(params.from))
                 where = dactyl.NEW_TAB;
-            background ^= !options.get("activate").has("all", params.from);
+            background ^= !options.get("activate").has(params.from);
         }
 
         if (urls.length == 0)
diff --git a/common/content/options.js b/common/content/options.js
index 7d51d6a6..7f05e8fe 100644
--- a/common/content/options.js
+++ b/common/content/options.js
@@ -376,6 +376,12 @@ const Option = Class("Option", {
      */
     SCOPE_BOTH: 3,
 
+    has: {
+        toggleAll: function toggleAll() toggleAll.supercall(this, "all")
+            ? Array.some(arguments, function (val) this.value.indexOf(val) === -1, this)
+            : toggleAll.superapply(this, arguments),
+    },
+
     parseRegex: function (value, result, flags) {
         let [, bang, val] = /^(!?)(.*)/.exec(value);
         let re = RegExp(Option.dequote(val), flags);
diff --git a/common/content/tabs.js b/common/content/tabs.js
index 3d6f552c..34d037be 100644
--- a/common/content/tabs.js
+++ b/common/content/tabs.js
@@ -784,7 +784,7 @@ const Tabs = Module("tabs", {
                     let tab = tabs.getTab();
 
                     let activate = args.bang ? true : false;
-                    if (options.get("activate").has("tabopen", "all"))
+                    if (options.get("activate").has("tabopen"))
                         activate = !activate;
 
                     for (let i in util.range(0, Math.max(1, args.count)))
@@ -1010,6 +1010,7 @@ const Tabs = Module("tabs", {
 
         if (config.hasTabbrowser) {
             let activateGroups = [
+                ["all", "Activate everything"],
                 ["addons", ":addo[ns] command"],
                 ["bookmarks", "Tabs loaded from bookmarks", "loadBookmarksInBackground"],
                 ["diverted", "Links with targets set to new tabs", "loadDivertedInBackground"],
@@ -1027,6 +1028,7 @@ const Tabs = Module("tabs", {
                 "stringlist", [g[0] for (g in values(activateGroups)) if (!g[2] || !options.getPref("browser.tabs." + g[2]))].join(","),
                 {
                     completer: function (context) activateGroups,
+                    has: Option.has.toggleAll,
                     setter: function (newValues) {
                         let valueSet = set(newValues);
                         for (let group in values(activateGroups))
@@ -1050,7 +1052,8 @@ const Tabs = Module("tabs", {
                         ["help", ":h[elp] command"],
                         ["javascript", ":javascript! or :js! command"],
                         ["prefs", ":pref[erences]! or :prefs! command"]
-                    ]
+                    ],
+                    has: Option.has.toggleAll
                 });
 
             // TODO: Is this really applicable to Melodactyl?
diff --git a/common/modules/sanitizer.jsm b/common/modules/sanitizer.jsm
index c53ad416..c43d57b3 100644
--- a/common/modules/sanitizer.jsm
+++ b/common/modules/sanitizer.jsm
@@ -228,13 +228,14 @@ const Sanitizer = Module("sanitizer", XPCOM([Ci.nsIObserver, Ci.nsISupportsWeakR
                 let items = args.slice();
                 if (args.bang) {
                     dactyl.assert(args.length == 0, "E488: Trailing characters");
-                    items = modules.options.get("sanitizeitems").values;
+                    items = Object.keys(sanitizer.itemDescriptions).filter(
+                        function (k) modules.options.get("sanitizeitems").has(k));
                 }
                 else
                     dactyl.assert(modules.options.get("sanitizeitems").validator(items), "Valid items required");
 
-                if (items[0] == "all")
-                    items = Object.keys(sanitizer.itemDescriptions);
+                if (items.indexOf("all") >= 0)
+                    items = Object.keys(sanitizer.itemDescriptions).filter(function (k) items.indexOf(k) === -1);
 
                 sanitizer.range = range;
                 sanitizer.ignoreTimespan = range.min == null;
@@ -305,9 +306,9 @@ const Sanitizer = Module("sanitizer", XPCOM([Ci.nsIObserver, Ci.nsISupportsWeakR
             "stringlist", "all",
             {
                 completer: function (value) Iterator(sanitizer.itemDescriptions),
+                has: modules.Option.has.toggleAll,
                 validator: function (values) values.length &&
-                    values.every(function (val) set.has(sanitizer.itemDescriptions, val)) &&
-                    (values.length == 1 || !values.some(function (val) val == "all"))
+                    values.every(function (val) val === "all" || set.has(sanitizer.itemDescriptions, val))
             });
 
         options.add(["sanitizetimespan", "sts"],